🟨 Under Review

Sacred Heart Church

509 Oswald Street | East Toledo
Built c. 1900

 

What it is:
Sacred Heart Church is a historic German Catholic parish in East Toledo. It's part of the Epiphany of the Lord Catholic Parish, clustered with St. Stephen and St. Thomas Aquinas. The Diocese of Toledo announced plans to close and demolish the building due to structural and financial concerns, despite community outcry and potential buyers.

​

Why it matters:
For generations, Sacred Heart Church stood at the spiritual and social center of East Toledo. More than a place of worship, it was a gathering space that helped shape neighborhood identity—hosting baptisms, weddings, funerals, festivals, and everyday moments of community life. Its architecture reflects a time when parish churches were designed not only for function, but to inspire awe and permanence.

 

Sacred Heart Church is a powerful reminder that preservation is not only about saving buildings, but about honoring the stories, traditions, and communities they represent.

 

What’s happening:
Since its closure, the building has faced an uncertain future. Vacancy brings increased risk of deterioration, vandalism, and eventual demolition—particularly in neighborhoods where redevelopment pressures and limited preservation resources collide. Once lost, a structure like Sacred Heart cannot be replaced, and with it goes a tangible link to the immigrant and working-class history of East Toledo.

​

What comes next:
The Toledo City Council has instituted a moratorium on demolition permits to protect historic structures, including Sacred Heart.

 

Status: 🟨 Under Review
Sources: City permit records; site observation; Toledo Blade new articles​